(the rest of the photos are here, by the way)
It seems like so long ago that the iPhone hit the market with a bang and it’s still considered by many to be the best cell phone you can get. Over the last year or two, many speculated about various concept phones and if any of them would be an “iPhone killer”, including me. One of those hopefuls was Google’s promise of a Google phone, which people quickly dubbed the “Gphone”. A few months after Apple brought us the second generation iPhone, T-Mobile announced the release of their Android-running G1 and people started to get excited about owning one.
I’ve seen a lot of other phones come out that seem to follow the iPhone’s lead in many of their features, but none have swayed me from my opinion that the iPhone is far superior. The only one that comes close so far is the HTC T-Mobile G1, so when I had a chance to compare the two side by side, I jumped on it. I played with the G1 for hours, taking pictures along the way before creating a comparison video and finally putting together my conclusions.
First, the technical comparison
(image from Wired)
(Note that the G1 also plays video)
One of the things I think the G1 really could have used is a multi-touch screen, but I guess I’m just spoiled by my iPhone. There have been rumors, but nothing solid yet. A standard headphone jack would be nice, too. You can always listen with USB headphones, but that limits your options. One area the G1 technically surpassed the iPhone was the built in camera. Delivering 3.2 mega pixels, it offers a much better picture than the iPhone’s 2.0 mega pixel camera.
Getting hands on
Part 1:
Part 2:
The videos above cover most of what I’ve played with, but here’s some of what I found that’s worth noting:
- The iPhone offers a sliding software lock and optional password protection, while the G1 employs the old method of hitting any button and then hit “Menu” to unlock the phone, but it also offers another cool option where you store a gesture pattern like a happy face or a cursive G and you repeat that gesture to unlock the phone.
- Both phones allow for multiple pages to display icons for key features and applications. The G1 sets itself apart here, though, allowing its owner to also display search boxes and widgets like the big clock we keep seeing in G1 photos. Better still, these can all be moved anywhere. The iPhone makes you stack your icons neatly, gravitating to the top left of the screen, but G1 is a wild child, letting you throw those suckers wherever you want. Rebel. To accommodate all this freedom, G1 tucks most of its icons in a little slide-out panel, so you can hide the stuff you use rarely and keep your key items on the main screens.
- Both platforms offer Google Maps. My iPhone has Google Earth. I’m not sure if the G1 offers Google Earth, but it includes Street View and Compass Mode, which is very cool. Just watch the video to see what I mean.
- Oddly, the Google Search app on the G1 didn’t work nearly as well as on my iPhone.
- It doesn’t appear that I can create picture folders in the g1 like I can in the iPhone, but that may just require more testing.
- Setting up email was incredibly easy on the g1. The iPhone requres me to go to the phone’s settings area to add or remove an email account which is a little annoying.
- Both phones offer easy access to a wealth of third-party applications, both paid, and free. They’re both, hands down, vastly better than the alternatives I’d become used to with Windows Mobile phones.
- Adding music with the g1 is as easy as dropping MP3s from my computer into the phone’s shared storage, but the sound quality pales compared to the iPhone. The iPhone’s music play back is loud and clear, while the G1’s is a bit muffled and tinny.
- G1’s roller ball can easily switch away from the text box in focus on accident if bumped, but is very handy in Street View. The integrated keyboard is tiny, but useful. My main problem here is that I have to physically slide it out every time I need to type something, which can be hard one-handed, unlike the iPhone, where the software keyboard just appears as needed. The mix of a hardware keyboard and an optional software keyboard that could be accessed with a quick tap would be a great improvement.
![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_b.png?x-id=29e2fe14-13af-4709-9847-ebcb69a9d03d)
del.icio.us
Stumble it!
on November 19th, 2008 at 1:02 am
Thanks for the great explanation…i love this one
umbultech’s last blog post..MySpace Japan
on November 19th, 2008 at 6:33 pm
umbultech: Thanks. I may have a much more detailed follow-up on the G1 in 3-4 weeks, so subscribe to the feed and watch for that
on November 20th, 2008 at 11:48 am
[...] Tech faced off the iPhone against Google’s g1 and posted a buttload of [...]
on November 21st, 2008 at 1:27 pm
[...] over at JoeTech got his hand on both the Apple iPhone and Google Android. Which one is better? Head on over to JoeTech and find [...]
on November 22nd, 2008 at 12:42 am
Nice review. But how old is your keyboard ffs!
on November 22nd, 2008 at 3:16 am
James: The older keyboards are the best. When mine dies, instead of heading to Best Buy, I head to the thrift store and seek out one of the old loud ones. They last forever, too. I go through keyboards like nobody’s business, so that’s important to me.
on December 3rd, 2008 at 5:17 pm
[...] as I was about to publish my iPhone vs G1 comparison, I received an email letting me know that T-Mobile was sending me a G1 to review. The phone arrived [...]
on December 19th, 2008 at 2:30 am
I was really looking for a review G1 vs iPhone because I was very interested in both phones and didn’t know what to choose. I think I’ll go with the G1 when it arrives here in Romania. Thanks again! ;)
Andrei Buiu’s last blog post..Writing from the heart
on May 18th, 2009 at 6:24 am
Come on dude, these facts* and proof* i mean who is posting* lol :P
on May 18th, 2009 at 1:31 pm
jailbreak: I don’t get where you’re coming from. Feel free to elaborate. Sadly, though, I suspect that you commented just for the link to your iphone unlocking page. Come on back and elaborate on what issue you take with the post.
on May 23rd, 2009 at 11:26 am
I am leaning towards the iPhone for my next phone. Or maybe the Palm Pre. I can see how the Google phone can be cool, but I want the iPhone most.
GigabyteFan’s last blog post..New Dish Network Channel: Fuel
on July 2nd, 2009 at 9:27 pm
Realy good job and service provided .I have any more information thanking you